Free shipping on orders over $35

Collection: Mystery Items

Collection of all mystery related items– when you're in the mood for a surprise!

Collection of 6 Real Mystery Snake Skins in Glass Vials

Collection of 6 Real Mystery Snake Skins in Glass Vials

Regular price $42.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $42.85 USD
One Mystery Coprolite Fossil (Fossilized Poop)

One Mystery Coprolite Fossil (Fossilized Poop)

Regular price $7.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $7.85 USD
One Large Mystery Coprolite Fossil (Fossilized Poop)

One Large Mystery Coprolite Fossil (Fossilized Poop)

Regular price $9.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.85 USD
Collection of 60 Mystery Mini Crystal Vials

Collection of 60 Mystery Mini Crystal Vials

Regular price $76.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $76.85 USD
Mystery Collection Vintage Animal Stamps – No. 01

Mystery Collection Vintage Animal Stamps – No. 01

Regular price $4.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.85 USD
One Hand Carved Agate Arrowhead – No. 02

One Hand Carved Agate Arrowhead – No. 02

Regular price $3.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $3.85 USD
Mystery Tiny Tarantula Leg in Glass Vial – No. 18

Mystery Tiny Tarantula Leg in Glass Vial – No. 18

Regular price $4.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.85 USD
One Real Mystery Rustic Cow Tooth in Kraft Box

One Real Mystery Rustic Cow Tooth in Kraft Box

Regular price $12.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $12.85 USD
One Real Mystery Mouse Tail in Glass Vial

One Real Mystery Mouse Tail in Glass Vial

Regular price $7.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $7.85 USD
One Real Mystery Snake Skin in Glass Vial, Labeled

One Real Mystery Snake Skin in Glass Vial, Labeled

Regular price $7.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $7.85 USD
One Real Large Rustic Mystery Cow Tooth in Kraft Box

One Real Large Rustic Mystery Cow Tooth in Kraft Box

Regular price $13.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $13.85 USD
Collection of 4 Real Mystery Snake Skins in Glass Vials

Collection of 4 Real Mystery Snake Skins in Glass Vials

Regular price $28.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $28.85 USD
Petite Mystery Tarantula Leg in Glass Vial

Petite Mystery Tarantula Leg in Glass Vial

Regular price $4.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.85 USD
Collection of 24 Mystery Mini Crystal Vials

Collection of 24 Mystery Mini Crystal Vials

Regular price $34.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $34.85 USD
One Hand Carved Agate Arrowhead – No. 03

One Hand Carved Agate Arrowhead – No. 03

Regular price $3.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $3.85 USD
Mystery Collection Vintage Butterfly Stamps – No. 01

Mystery Collection Vintage Butterfly Stamps – No. 01

Regular price $3.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $3.85 USD
Mystery Collection Vintage Bird Stamps – No. 01

Mystery Collection Vintage Bird Stamps – No. 01

Regular price $3.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $3.85 USD
Mystery Petite Tarantula Molt in Glass Vial – No. 01

Mystery Petite Tarantula Molt in Glass Vial – No. 01

Regular price $9.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.85 USD
One Real Tiny Mystery Feather in Tiny Glass Vial

One Real Tiny Mystery Feather in Tiny Glass Vial

Regular price $3.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $3.85 USD
One Hand Carved Agate Arrowhead – No. 01

One Hand Carved Agate Arrowhead – No. 01

Regular price $4.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.85 USD
Real Mystery Snake Skin in Glass Vial, Unlabeled

Real Mystery Snake Skin in Glass Vial, Unlabeled

Regular price $5.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $5.85 USD
Mystery Petite Tarantula Molt in Glass Vial – No. 02

Mystery Petite Tarantula Molt in Glass Vial – No. 02

Regular price $9.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $9.85 USD
Mystery Tiny Tarantula Leg in Glass Vial

Mystery Tiny Tarantula Leg in Glass Vial

Regular price $5.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $5.85 USD
One Real Mystery Tiny Coprolite Fossil in Glass Dome

One Real Mystery Tiny Coprolite Fossil in Glass Dome

Regular price $15.85 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.85 USD